There was an article in Washington D.C.'s The Onion about the city's best milkshakes. Since I didn't really have much else to do, I decided to investigate these stately claims myself. Of course I needed to go about the whole thing scientifically. I mean, when there are milkshakes involved, one has to take the uttermost care in ensuring evenhandedness and fairness in the ranking system. The scientific method must be followed. It's extremely arduous work. Not for the faint of heart.
I decided that, to ensure fairness in the ranking process, there must be a control shake flavor. I picked vanilla. It's my second favorite ice cream flavor, right behind chocolate chip cookie dough. But it also has a depth of flavor that can vary greatly from place to place. For ranking categories, I chose taste, texture, size, value. Results are on a 1-5 scale, 1 being the worst, 5 being the best.
The Restaurant: Ben's Chile Bowl 1213 U Street, N.W.

The Shake:

Ben's Chili Bowl and I do not have a good history. Both times that I went there they messed up my order. But on the paper's recommendation, I decided to give it another try.
The Results:
Taste: 3 The shake had a sweet, but sightly syrupy vanilla taste.
Texture: 4 I like my shakes very thick and this one was one of the thickest that I've ever had. However, it was a little too icy.
Size: 2 As you can see, the shake can in a generic soda cup. Not that big. Maybe on the smallish side.
Value: 3 At three dollars and some change, this was the cheapest shake in the competition.
Restaurant: The Diner 459 18th St NW

The Shake:

The Diner is in the Adam's Morgan neighborhood in Washington D.C. It's a longish uphill walk from the closest metro station.
The Results:
Taste: 4 This shake had a more French Vanilla flavor than average run-of-the-mill vanilla shake.
Texture: 4 This was a tough one to judge. As stated, I prefer a thick shake. This shake had a much more whipped and fluffy consistency. I've never had a shake quite like it before. So, for uniqueness, I give this a 4.
Size: 5 Served in a large plastic cup. The see through factor is much appreciated as it allows one to see the delicious innards.
Value: 2 Unfortunately, at five dollars and change, this was the most expensive shake.
At this point in the experiment I had to take a break. I had already consumed two shakes and had walked uphill in the heat. I quickly sought shelter in the form of a bench in the shade of a tree. I literally could not move for a half hour without feeling nauseous. I decided to end the experiment for the day and continue the next day.
Some photos from around the area:




Could Project Runway's Blayne have written this sign? "licious" = gag. Blayne needs to go. And has anyone noticed that he always spells "licious" wrong on the little chalkboard in the Atlas apartment? He always spells it, "licous." The tanning must have melted the part of his brain that controls spelling and the ability to use a dictionary. Seriously, he needs to get kicked off the show. Between him and Suede, I'm beginning to believe the rumor that the producers are sabotaging the show before its move to Lifetime.
Day 2
The Restaurant: American City Diner 5532 Connecticut Ave, N.W.

The Shake:
Not Pictured (served in a tall Styrofoam cup).
The American City Diner is a throwback to the diners of yesteryear. Chrome, aluminum, neon, and vintage bricabrac festooned the walls.


There was even a sassy waitress a la Alice, Cheers, etc. Let my tell you, in real life, those sassy waitresses are kind of uncomfortable to be around. I wasn't sure if I was supposed to sass back, make a self-deprecating one liner, or treat her like a normal waitress. I really just wanted to pay for my shake and leave. I guess this is another one of those things that in real life isn't as funny as it is on tv.
The Results:
Taste: 3 This was your typical vanilla shake. Straight up vanilla ice cream and milk.
Texture: 3 Smooth and creamy, but no real surprises.
Size: 3 The Styrofoam cup was your the typical large sized soda cup.
Value: 4 At four dollars and change, this was a nice value.
The Restaurant: Good Stuff Eatery 303 Pennsylvania Ave, S.E.

The Shake:

I actually decided to go for the Toasted Marshmallow Milkshake because, well, it's a frickin' TOASTED MARSHMALLOW MILKSHAKE! I was also tempted to get the MilkyWay Milkshake too. But I knew that if I got them both, both of them would eventually end up splattering on the sidewalk as it exited my mouth at high speed velocity.
I almost didn't get to this restaurant. The paper listed the address as 303 Penn. Ave. and I assumed that it meant N.W. Penn. Ave. Well, I got off the metro and spent a good chunk of time walking down the street looking for the place. But I only saw government building after government building. Then I thought that maybe The Onion meant S.W. Penn. Ave. So I called the restaurant and, yep, S.W. Penn. Ave. Grr. It annoys me when people don't wright down the entire street address. This wasn't the first time something like that has happened to me. Is it really that hard to include an extra two letters? So, I went back on the metro and headed south.
The Results:
Taste: 2 Sadly, I found that the toasted marshmallow milkshake did not meet my high expectations. It had an odd graham cracker taste. Possibly a s'more milkshake? The toasted marshmallows on top were a nice touch.
Texture: 4 Super thick.
Size: 3 A tad on the small side.
Value: 3 At five bucks and change, the shake was a little too expensive for what it delivered.
And now, the moment you've all been waiting for...the rankings! (not an average. 1=best, 4=worst)
1. The Diner
2. Ben's Chili Bowl
3. The American City Diner
4. Good Stuff Eatery
I'm going to go back next week to Good Stuff Eatery to try their vanilla shake.
Chatboard (0)